From spouses to sons to nieces, family shows up on the payroll at more small firms than you might expect. Whether that ends up being a blessing or regret has more to do with the lines drawn around it than with who gets hired.

Cathryn Vidal didn’t have to look far for a firm name when starting her firm. She simply spelled out her family.

“It’s Cathryn, Ryan, Ellie, Maddie,” she says, “and then there’s an A for, I don’t know, Associates.”

At the time, Crema Bookkeeping was a family business in name only. Today, it’s a family business in every sense of the word. Ryan, her husband, spent years running restaurant kitchens as a chef before trading his knives for a bookkeeping certificate and joining the Vancouver Island firm. He’s now Vidal’s partner.

So who’s in charge? Their daughters have it all figured out.

If you were to ask my kids, they would say that I’m the boss at work and he’s the boss at home,” Vidal says, before adding with a laugh, “Unless he’s being mean, then I’m the boss at home as well.”
cathryn vidal Cathryn Vidal

Tyler Otto tells a very different story. When it came time to make his first hire at Specialized Accounting, he didn’t trust anyone outside his inner circle, so he brought on family. It’s a decision he hasn’t revisited since.

While family is lovely,” Otto says, “never will do that again.”
tyler otto Tyler Otto

Differences of opinion, particularly over company culture, complicated the working relationships. He says he’s still on good terms with those relatives, but is glad they no longer work together.

Same move, opposite outcomes. And Vidal and Otto aren’t outliers. Among the small-firm owners we spoke with, family on the team was surprisingly common, and opinions about it were anything but lukewarm.

Conventional business wisdom has an easy answer to this: never mix family and business. But the owners who’ve actually lived it tell a more nuanced story.

So what separates the firms where family on the team works from the ones where it falls apart?

As it turns out, it’s rarely the family member or even the relationship. It’s the boundaries, boundaries between the relationships you already have and the working relationships you’re trying to build.

The Upside: A Shared Language and Skills You Can’t Hire

When the family on the team works, it works remarkably well. For some owners, it means having someone who already understands the job. For others, it brings skills they’d struggle to find anywhere else.

The biggest benefit for Christine Salvatore was something she didn’t know she was missing. Her husband, Jack, spent years working in post-production while she built In Line Management, her production accounting firm. Every time she wanted to vent about a difficult situation or talk through a decision, she had to start from the beginning.

I would tell him some of the issues I was having in my company or some drama that happened that day, and it would come with me having to explain a whole backstory,” Salvatore says.
christine salvatore Christine Salvatore

Then Jack joined the firm, with his own clients and a full-time salary comparable to what he earned in post-production. The arrangement leaves him extra hours to pursue writing, his other ambition. As a result, the two are now “on this entrepreneurial journey together,” as Salvatore puts it.

I’m able to be like, ‘This person sent me this email.’ And he’s like, ‘No,’” she says. “He understands it instantly instead of me having to be like, ‘Here’s why that’s a problem.’”
christine salvatore Christine Salvatore

Before, the only people she could brainstorm with were clients or “employees who were being paid to talk to me.” Now, she has a partner who gets it. “I feel more seen,” she says.

At Crema, Vidal got something just as valuable. Ryan didn’t stroll into the firm on the strength of his last name. He completed two bookkeeping courses and trained hands-on alongside Vidal and her bookkeepers until he was “fully up to speed.” But he also brought habits from the kitchen, where he sat down once a week to review every line item on the restaurant’s financials and account for every dollar spent. “So he already has that kind of analytical mind,” Vidal says.

Today, he’s the one who digs into client financials and talks with clients about “where their money is going and what changes they can make to improve their bottom line.”

His kitchen experience paid off in another way, too. Vidal had never managed employees before Crema, and some of her early hires were, in her words, “terrible.” Years of running a kitchen staff made Ryan the person she could lean on while she learned.

Luckily Ryan had all that experience from chefing,” she says. “So he was able to help me a lot.”
cathryn vidal Cathryn Vidal

For Lynn James-Young, family involvement runs across generations. Two of her three sons are part of Bring It Bookkeeping. Two years ago, she convinced her oldest to join the firm full-time, and she’s now “teaching him the ropes.” Her middle son holds a senior role at another company, but he’s still her go-to IT person on the side. “And believe me,” James-Young says, “I need IT help.”

Melissa Miller Furgeson’s son took a different path into Bookkeeping for Good. The college student, who studies statistics and computer science, spent a summer working for the firm “sort of as an intern,” and he put his coursework to use.

He automated a bunch of stuff for us,” Miller Furgeson says. “And that helped us control the workload.”
melissa miller furgeson Melissa Miller Furgeson

He still runs those automations every week from school. And while he’s off to an internship at a big company in New York this summer, she’s hopeful he’ll come back to the firm someday.

At Mindfull Money Matters, family was there from the very first client. Angela Jenkins’s family owns a janitorial company where her cousins do the work, and when they asked who would handle the finances, the answer was her. That company became her first client, and her brother-in-law was likely her second. Family helped get her firm off the ground. But the advantages don’t erase the friction.

There are days when it’s super trying,” Jenkins says.
angela jenkins Angela Jenkins

Family can bring a firm an understanding and a set of skills it might not otherwise find. But as Jenkins’s candor suggests, the same closeness that makes these arrangements work can also make them harder.

The Pitfalls: Where It Often Goes Wrong

For every owner who credits family with making their firm stronger, there’s another who learned the hard way how messy it can get. Otto is one of them.

When he made his first hire, he was still finding his footing as a firm owner, and trust was an issue.

I didn’t know what I was doing,” he says. “I was afraid. I couldn’t trust anyone. So I hired family.”
tyler otto Tyler Otto

On paper, it was the safe choice: people he already knew, already loved, and already trusted. In practice, it was anything but simple.

Just complicates everything,” Otto says, “especially when you have differences in opinions on how the company culture should be.”
tyler otto Tyler Otto

That’s the catch. Disagreements about culture are tough with any employee. But when the person across the table is family, there’s no clean way to have the conversation, and no easy way to walk away from it. It’s why Otto is so emphatic that he “never will do that again,” even though the relationships came through intact.

Still great with those family members,” he says. “Just so happy I don’t do that anymore.”
tyler otto Tyler Otto

The interesting thing is that Specialized Accounting is a family business at its core. In 2017, Otto’s wife, who holds a master’s degree in biomedical engineering, launched a bookkeeping practice she could run from home while they raised their kids. Then the pandemic hit, and Otto’s career running finance departments for luxury hotels went with it. Suddenly, the couple had a choice to make: chase another corporate job, or take a bookkeeping firm bringing in $20,000 a year and try to build something bigger.

So I stole her firm, usurped—no, she hired me,” Otto jokes. “Let’s go with that.”
tyler otto Tyler Otto

Today, his wife is no longer in the day-to-day, but she’s still involved. She runs payroll, handles some admin work, and oversees the firm’s pro bono work for a handful of nonprofits whose boards she sits on. So Otto’s story isn’t really about family being a bad idea. It’s about what happens when the working relationship lacks clear boundaries.

Even in a family arrangement that has gone well, the personal relationship can make ordinary workplace conversations harder. Helle’s arrangement with her niece, who serves as her admin at Scaled Accounting Solutions, is by all accounts a success. They have a firm rule: “work is work and family is completely separate,” and nearly a year in, Helle says her niece is “doing really great.”

Still, not long ago, her niece approached her with a confession. “She goes, I need to talk to you about something, but I’m a little nervous,” Helle recalls.

Surprised, she asked her niece whether she’d ever given her a reason to feel like she couldn’t come to her. Her niece said no. “But you’re my family,” she told her.

From Helle’s side, the boundary was clear. But for the family member, especially a younger one working for someone who has always been an aunt first, raising a work issue can feel like putting the relationship on the line.

That’s usually where the trouble starts. Personal history follows family members into a professional relationship, and without clear expectations about how the work gets done, even a well-intentioned family hire can create problems neither side saw coming.

Questions to Ask Before You Hire Family

  • Would I hire this person if they weren’t family?
    Otto made his first hire mostly out of fear. He didn’t think he could trust anyone else. Before you make an offer, be honest about whether it’s a business decision or a comfort one.
  • What exactly will they own?
    Jack Salvatore has his own clients. Ryan Vidal handles client conversations about the numbers. A role with clear responsibilities is harder to blur than a standing offer to “help out.”
  • Do they have the skills, or the time to learn them?
    Ryan completed two bookkeeping courses and trained hands-on before taking on clients. Helle’s niece came in with no firm experience, which meant no bad habits to break and Helle could train her how she wanted. It also meant a much bigger investment in training. Plan for that up front.
  • Do we see the firm the same way?
    Otto’s family hires came apart over different views of what the company culture should be. Have that conversation from day one, not after the first disagreement.
  • Will they feel safe telling me something’s wrong?
    Even in an arrangement that works, Helle’s niece was nervous to raise a work issue with her aunt. Make it clear early, and often, that at work, it’s business.
  • How much work are we willing to bring home?
    The Salvatores talk shop a lot, so they deliberately make time for things that have nothing to do with the firm. Decide together where the work stops.
  • What happens if they want to leave?
    Miller Furgeson’s son left for an internship in New York, and she’s hopeful he’ll come back someday. James-Young’s middle son has his own career and still helps with IT on the side. The best family arrangements leave room to move on without straining the relationship.

Lessons Learned: Drawing the Line

So how do the owners who make it work keep family and business from bleeding into each other? They decide, out loud, where work ends and family begins, and then they hold to it.

Helle may have the most explicit version of this. When she hired her niece, the two agreed on a single rule from the start: “Work is work and family is completely separate.” Helle draws the same line with the relatives she serves as clients.

Everyone is always like, ‘How do you do it? How do you have family work for you?’” Helle says. “I draw really hard boundaries. I’m very good at it. This is personal… and then business is business.”
katie helle Katie Helle

That’s why her niece’s nervous confession didn’t turn into a bigger problem. Helle didn’t brush it off, and she didn’t treat it as personal. She asked if she ever gave her niece a reason to feel she couldn’t come to her. Then she restated the rule: “You have to remember, this is business.”

The point was to give her niece permission to bring up a work problem the way any employee would, without worrying that it might cost her something at the next family dinner.

Vidal draws the line a little more playfully, but just as clearly. Her daughters will tell you exactly who’s in charge where: Mom at work, Dad at home. The division of roles carries into the business, too. Vidal describes herself as the one who says yes to every opportunity that comes along, while Ryan “definitely plans.” Because they lead in different areas, they rarely compete.

He’s my partner in everything, and I think we really complement each other,” Vidal says. “So, haven’t had any issues yet, knock on wood.”
cathryn vidal Cathryn Vidal

For Salvatore, the challenge is how much of the work follows them home. Having a spouse who understands the business is a gift, but it also means the business never fully leaves the room.

We do talk about work a lot,” Salvatore admits.
christine salvatore Christine Salvatore

But she noticed that their conversations could become an endless loop of business and childcare logistics. So they started playing childhood games around the house, like hide-and-seek, and posting the videos on Instagram. It sounds small, but Salvatore says it worked.

It’s kind of broken—this, like, always talking about work and then always talking about logistics with the kids,” she says. “And it’s brought more fun back into our day-to-day.”
christine salvatore Christine Salvatore

James-Young draws her line through how she develops people. She doesn’t hire people to take orders. She hires them to think like owners.

I’m not there to boss them around,” James-Young says. “I’m there to help them think and solve problems.”
lynn james-young Lynn James-Young

That approach is especially useful when the new hire is your son. A family member who’s learning to think and solve problems for himself has a real role in the firm. He isn’t just helping Mom out, and that makes the line between work and family easier for everyone to see.

These owners don’t all draw the line in the same place. Helle keeps work and family firmly apart. The Vidals and the Salvatores let the two overlap, on terms they’ve agreed to. What they share is that the line is drawn on purpose, and everyone involved knows where it is.

The Rule

At work, a family member should be able to raise problems, ask questions, and disagree the same way any employee would, without worrying that it will damage the relationship.

When Helle’s niece hesitated to raise a work issue because “you’re my family,” Helle could have brushed it off or taken it personally. But she reminded her of the line they’d agreed on from the start:

“You have to remember, this is business.”
— Katie Helle, Founder of Scaled Accounting Solutions

Bring In Family (Or Don’t) on Your Own Terms

There’s no universal verdict on hiring family. Vidal describes her husband as her partner in everything and says they complement each other. Salvatore appreciates having someone at home who understands the pressures of running a business. For Otto, bringing family members into the firm complicated working relationships in ways he wouldn’t repeat. They are all telling the truth about their own experiences.

None of them is wrong. Bringing family into the business isn’t universally good or bad. It’s a decision that plays out differently depending on the people, the roles, and, above all, how clearly the lines are drawn. The owners who are happiest with the arrangement decide ahead of time how to handle it.

That may be the most “Proudly Small” part of this story. Owners of small firms don’t have to follow anyone else’s rules about who belongs on their team, whether that rule comes from a growth guru or a generations-old warning against mixing family and business. They get to build on their own terms.

For some, that means building a firm alongside the people they love most. For others, it means deliberately keeping work and family apart. Either way, it is their call to make.

Be among the first to know

Enter your email address to receive new issues of the magazine straight to your inbox.